It’s the second time in three years that a team has failed winning back to back premierships, leaving us all to wonder, is it possible in today’s AFL league? The cats had gone from champs to legends, but in 07, 09, and 11, always a year in between. Even the super swans failed back in 06, but came a lot closer than the cats in 08 and the Pies in 2011. But why are they failing? Being a cats supporter and going through it I did learn a few things. It seems the biggest killers after winning a premiership are ego’s and complacency. You have just won a grand final the supporters have waited 44 years for, and every minute out of every day, one of them is pulling you aside to tell you you’re a God, wanting to shake your hand, hug you, take photo’s etc. And this goes on for at least the next 6-12 months. How can your ego not inflate? In the olden days players were God s, but did not have quite the hysteria and huge fanatical supporter bases there are today. Collingwood alone has at least 80,000 members and probably still counting...unfortunately. Despite the fact that winning a premiership is the ultimate feeling for an AFL player, and they would do anything to feel it again ASAP, this just doesn’t seem to be enough to make it happen. Because the recipe for success has worked so well, and has achieved the ultimate, the players become set in their ways, i.e. the way they play, and the complacency sets in. So no matter what another team throws at them, which should prompt a change in their game plan, the players continue to play the same way regardless of the situation. And what helps to breed the complacency is the fact that despite being set in their ways, the team keeps winning by huge margins! So fair enough they think there is no reason to change, right? Unfortunately in time, this formula for success will fail, when a genuine hungry challenger, who hasn’t won the cup before, uses their brains, and adapts to knock the kings off their throne. At the end of 08, Hawthorn achieved this by winning the grand final, beating the cats. The cats were in shock after their formula had won them nearly every game for the year except the one that counted. Coach mark Thompson was the 1st to shed light on why the cats had failed.: ‘I felt the players were playing without listening’. It suddenly all made sense. Why would they follow what the coach was saying, when without him, they would still win the game by 60 points? After that loss in the 08 grand final, the cats were devastated and had something to prove in 09. They wanted to play using their heads, and they wanted a plan A, b and c so they could adapt when things went wrong. Some people say footballers don’t have many brains, when the fact is they do, they just need a bit of a push when it comes to knowing how to use them. That’s how the cats won in 09, they used their heads and came prepared for any possible challenge. The saints thought it was their destiny to win in 09, being the best team all year. Unfortunately this may have made them somewhat take their foot off the pedal on grand final day, feeling like it was already in their pocket. The cats also wanted to be super fit to ensure they could beat any other team. Last but not least, they had hunger again, because it had been a year or two since winning the big one. Hunger seems to be extremely important when going for the ultimate, but as we saw with the saints in 2010, all the hunger in the world can’t win you one if you don’t have the cattle or the natural talent. Just the pain of losing one wasn’t enough. The cats pulled off another amazing win though in 09, with a gap year since the last Premiership in 07.
Cats premiers in 07, The Abletts
Hawks premiers in 08, Gaz with a little less hair
Cats premiers in 09
Luke Ball decestated after the Saints lose the 09 Grand Final
Flash forward to the cats at the end of 2010, who were again going for back to back. In their qualifying final, against the saints they played for 3 quarter with the enthusiasm of a farmer in a dry spell or a gay guy at goldifngers...therefore none. By the time the complacency had worn off and the cats realised the game was slipping away, it was too late. Perhaps they were never going to win back to back because the complacency had set in early in the season again, and they had not trained as hard in pre season as was required. I seemed to recall the cats either getting an extra month off or lighter training load after winning in 09.
Cats coach Bomber had allegedly tried to change the cats game style in 2010 to account for the Pies ‘press’, but was he really backpedalling with this comment? Did he know he was going to Essendon, and then became a saboteur? Or did Mark himself become a bit complacent and should have taken charge and forced change, rather than merely suggest it?
The Pies were now the champions, smashing the cats in the preliminary final of 2010, and despite a slight hiccup with the grand final draw, due to the fact that their best player decided to play with gastro, they completely dominated in the second 2010 grand final. It was their turn to go back to back. And by the end of 2011, I could start to see that what happened to the cats, was now happening to the Pies. The Pies looked like they were playing without listening. Mick Malthouse had smoke coming out his ears at times because the ego’s were understandably inflated and they were becoming complacent without even noticing. They, like the cats in 08 were winning every game and winning well, but when challenged, were lost like an 80 year old on a speed dating night. Those ego’s so strong and confident prevented the players from realising they were in trouble, all too late.
Grand final draw 2010
Pies 2010 Premiers
Pies on the big day in 2011
At ¾ time in the 2011 grand final, Pendlebury said the pies were right in there with the cats, but for some reason, they were powerless to stop the cats running away from them. Having missed out on the 2010 grand final, the cats were hungry again this year. Complacency gone, the talent was still there, add a new coach, and losing their best player had produced a whole new drive for the team. Everyone said they were too old, too slow, and couldn’t win one without Gazza. So the cats again had a point to prove, determined to hush the critics. And when the cats try to prove a point, they do it! It was an unstoppable force. After the 08 grand final Paul Chapman was burnt and said they were never to lose to hawthorn again,.. and they haven’t. The team also vowed to never lose another grand final again, and they had stayed true to their word.
Collingwood had put in place a plan so that they could overcome failing at back to back flags. They put all their trust in their fitness staff who took them to Arizona for high altitude training. It was supposed to create a superior fitness, but unfortunately this was done at the start of the season, and by the end, the effects were wearing thin. The pies seemed to rely too heavily on their fitness staff and became like dependant kids who had lost control of their own destiny. They forgot to take charge of their own responsibilities, and became complacent. On top of it, the cats were trialling a ‘heavy training program’ a month or two before the finals, which ultimately trumped Arizona. The revolutionary program had only been trialled by a young Crows team once and had failed. So it seemed risky with a team full of 30 year olds. Their form did slump initially, but in time the cats worked their butts off to become super fit for the finals. It was again their year, after winning in 07 ,09 and slumping in their back to back years of 08 and 2010. It was another odd year so the drive was back and it was time. We were lead to believe it was Collingwood’s year, but like a good reality TV show, the team you are lead to believe will win, never does. And certainly not without a year in between of serious soul searching, hunger and vengeance rebuilding . The cats had taken vengeance on the team that destroyed them the previous year, and didn’t stop punishing until the final siren. Whether the Cats can pull off the impossible task of winning back to back flags next year in 2012, remains to be seen, and looks to remain a huge challenge for years to come.
THE GAME
The Pies played well mostly, magnificent at stages. Pendles’ was also strong until the last quarter, but it wasn’t enough. Early on the Pies fans had started their arrogant chant a little too soon. Most clubs had a standard chant of saying the teams name, and then clapping 3 times. But the Pies felt they were better, and deserved to have a unique call. It was simply their name drawn out: ‘COLL-INGWOOOD’. I suppose the sweetest moment for cats fans was the last ten minutes, when the entire stadium of cats supporters began a mock chant: ‘GEEEE-LOOOONG, GEEEE-LOOOONG’ . It was the highlight of the day, and put that arrogance back in its place. A timely reminder not to claim the game too early. The players would have loved hearing it, as it was payback for the Pies fans who began the chant a year ago in the prelim final against the cats.
Mitch 'Slam Dunc' Duncans first grand final
Gary Ablett had sold his soul for 10 million and lost himself a premiership. Was it worth it? Joel Selwood and Jimmy Bartel had resisted the same temptation from the Gold Coast and GWS, to keep their champion team together. Selwood said he knew that in order to keep the talented playing group together, and in order for continued success for the footy club, he would have to take a pay cut. They would all need to. So loyalty, and unselfish acts like that helped the cats win a third premiership. That was the character of a real man that deserved respect. The Pies took pay cuts and then smiled, relaxed and said great, we’re all together still, that should be enough right??? Wrong.
Collingwood had put in place a plan so that they could overcome failing at back to back flags. They put all their trust in their fitness staff who took them to Arizona for high altitude training. It was supposed to create a superior fitness, but unfortunately this was done at the start of the season, and by the end, the effects were wearing thin. The pies seemed to rely too heavily on their fitness staff and became like dependant kids who had lost control of their own destiny. They forgot to take charge of their own responsibilities, and became complacent. On top of it, the cats were trialling a ‘heavy training program’ a month or two before the finals, which ultimately trumped Arizona. The revolutionary program had only been trialled by a young Crows team once and had failed. So it seemed risky with a team full of 30 year olds. Their form did slump initially, but in time the cats worked their butts off to become super fit for the finals. It was again their year, after winning in 07 ,09 and slumping in their back to back years of 08 and 2010. It was another odd year so the drive was back and it was time. We were lead to believe it was Collingwood’s year, but like a good reality TV show, the team you are lead to believe will win, never does. And certainly not without a year in between of serious soul searching, hunger and vengeance rebuilding . The cats had taken vengeance on the team that destroyed them the previous year, and didn’t stop punishing until the final siren. Whether the Cats can pull off the impossible task of winning back to back flags next year in 2012, remains to be seen, and looks to remain a huge challenge for years to come.
Captain Ling and coach Scott hold up the cup in 2011
2011 happy Cats
2011 Premiers pose
THE MEDIA CONFERENCE
After the game a content Jimmy Bartel sat with first year coach Chris Scott, 2 medals around his neck (Norm Smith and Premiership medal), and he talked about another amazing year at the club. Jimmy particularly mentioned the new focus and rejuvenation in the group. It was obviously a freshness lacking in the years after their premierships, and indeed a reason Gary Ablett had been lured away, for a fresh new challenge. Jimmy wore his Norm Smith medal proudly for best on ground, which he called ‘icing’. The man was modest! He could play in any position, and out-mark a player of any size. He could also kick goals from any position, which he attributed to practicing his barrels at training. And was again modest when he mentioned that he only thought they had the pies with 2 minutes to go. I wanted to ask if he had a different feeling with all 3 of the premierships, but before I could someone jumped in and asked it for me. I suspected I knew the answer anyway: of course they are all special! But Jimmy got a kick out of seeing the younger players win one too. Even though it meant Mooney and Milburn had to miss out, Jimmy commented on how special they are, and that they mean just as much to the team as Menzel and Vardy who also missed out.
Coach Chris Scott and Norm Smith winner Jimmy Bartel
Coach Scott was overwhelmed and said the feeling was the same, winning one as a player and coach. The players didn’t depend completely on Scott though. They rather worked with him and vice versa to get the best out of each other. Suddenly it was all the craze to get a new/young coach, and the old coaches were on the outs due to the Cats success now. Scott mentioned that injuries were a factor on the day. They didn’t know till 10am on the day, that Steve Johnson was right, and there was some concern when Pods went down, but Scott was confident Ottens and West would lift. Even if Hawkins hadn’t lifted , the coaches still had faith in his future. Taylor also had a head knock on the day, but the other three tall defenders stood up. He acknowledged that the team that wins the most contests wins the game, and at the start of the year they said they still needed to improve on this too, as they are a super competitive bunch. Scott said he worked on defence with the team, but the players were so well coached, that they were 95% ready for this grand final, with years of good preparation under their belts. He had his doubts initially but after 6 weeks he saw something remarkable with so many games won in 5 years, he knew he had walked into a special club. Scott also talked about his emotions in the box for the day. He felt fortunate and humble. Fortunate for the assistant coaches he had, but he said the players needed the credit for this.
Coach Chris Scotts' take on the day
THE GAME
The Cats had come from nearly 20 points down in the 2nd quarter, and run away with a special win. A man with a busted knee had kicked 4 goals (Johnson), and a lost boy (Hawkins) had taken 9 contested marks, out of nowhere to help seal the game and nearly take the norm smith. He was a boy who looked disinterested and unmotivated all year. Even Selwood, a poor shot for goal, kicked 2. A man called Varcoe who had looked lethargic of late, kicked three goals including the first 2. And Jimmy Bartel (the best player in the league) had more room to shine with Ablett gone.
The Pies played well mostly, magnificent at stages. Pendles’ was also strong until the last quarter, but it wasn’t enough. Early on the Pies fans had started their arrogant chant a little too soon. Most clubs had a standard chant of saying the teams name, and then clapping 3 times. But the Pies felt they were better, and deserved to have a unique call. It was simply their name drawn out: ‘COLL-INGWOOOD’. I suppose the sweetest moment for cats fans was the last ten minutes, when the entire stadium of cats supporters began a mock chant: ‘GEEEE-LOOOONG, GEEEE-LOOOONG’ . It was the highlight of the day, and put that arrogance back in its place. A timely reminder not to claim the game too early. The players would have loved hearing it, as it was payback for the Pies fans who began the chant a year ago in the prelim final against the cats.
The younger cats players chipped in for the victory. Duncan was almost a blessing in disguise after Pods dislocated a shoulder, and went off. ‘Slam Dunc’ scored a goal in his first grand final and Allen ‘call me all’ Christensen took a big mark between 2 pies players, the tiny man asserting his dominance, impressively. The Moon dog and Milburn were missing, but so was the ‘MENZ!’ Menzel. I don’t think I’ve cried at a footy match since I was 8, but when the Menz went down in the qualifying final against the Hawks, I lost it. I knew he had cost himself a premiership, and it wasn’t even worth it dislocating a knee after the ball had already gone out of bounds. He kicked 5 goals against the Pies in round 24, and was a young gun all year that prompted thrills. ‘The MENZ! You cant stop the MENZ’ was my call. Evidently a knee reco can stop the Menz. But from his work during the year, he was as much a part of the win as the injured Pods.
Selwood steps up again
Magic 'Johno' Johnson
The ever reliable Bartel
Trav 'Varcs' Varcoe on fire Tom 'Tomahawk' Hawkins also steps up
Mitch 'Slam Dunc' Duncans first grand final
Corey 'Borris' Enright the joker
Al 'call me Al' Christensen
You can't even tackle this guy!
Pods goes down
Joel 'Smitty' Corey, and Matty Scarlett
THE ROOMS
The Cats players sipped beers, talked to family , friends, media and the adoring fans casually, like normal human beings would. Borris Enright inspected his boots while casually chatting about anything with the fam’, not necessarily the game or his huge achievement . Comedian ‘Jimmy’ James Kelly joked with his family and friends. And Tom Hawkins looked like he was getting a talking to from a family member or friend. He was getting some advice perhaps? Not that he needed it after his last quarter domination. They were acting like mere mortals, even though they had become immortal that day. They even had their kids with them. Harry Taylor was famous for taking his tiny baby James Taylor on the cats victory lap, to the tune of we are the champions. Everyone close was there. Even dual premiership captain Tom Harley chatted with Tom ‘Lonnas’ Lonergan. Lonergan lost a kidney playing for the club and risked his life every day since to play for the club. That has to be a well earnt premiership! It was a great place to be. It was a stark contrast to the Pies rooms which would have been quiet and full of sadness. Geelong and their
supporters were familiar with this in the early 90’s. There was a slight melancholy in the Cats rooms, with Cam moony and Darren Milburn sitting off to the side with old mate Kent Kingsley, who had let himself go, and lost a fair bit of hair since retirement. Kent present was his name in the day, known for plenty of marks but not goals unfortunately. They all shared a bitter sweet drink after missing out, but got to watch the team win. The immortals boarded the team bus to greet their fans at Fed Square and deservedly have their egos inflate once more :-). Happy for the third time in 5 years, with 4 grand final appearances, for three wins.
The song in the roomssupporters were familiar with this in the early 90’s. There was a slight melancholy in the Cats rooms, with Cam moony and Darren Milburn sitting off to the side with old mate Kent Kingsley, who had let himself go, and lost a fair bit of hair since retirement. Kent present was his name in the day, known for plenty of marks but not goals unfortunately. They all shared a bitter sweet drink after missing out, but got to watch the team win. The immortals boarded the team bus to greet their fans at Fed Square and deservedly have their egos inflate once more :-). Happy for the third time in 5 years, with 4 grand final appearances, for three wins.
THE AFTERMATH
The happiness of winning a grand final lives on if you read all the newspaper articles in the week, and particularly the day after the grand final. Relive the magic, the moments, and find out all the secret goss’ about the injuries and efforts to get players ready for the big day. Steve Johnson thought he wasn’t going to be playing about 10 times during the week before the game, it was that touch and go. The pies had made a great deal about leaving out the injured beams, but perhaps failed by leaving in both Jolly and Reed, who struggled on the day in the end, when needed. The cats celebrated at fed square with a huge portion of supporters gathered to greet them, and the cup! They even re-inacted the mock ’GEEE-LOONG’ chant for the players again as
Billy got to pump up the glory for a third time. I think it all hit home though, looking at a pic of Cameron Ling, on the front of the herald sun, the Monday after the grand final. He was holding all three premiership cups, with the headline ‘Cat Trick’. I loved the pic, but for some reason, about the fourth time I looked at it, I became overwhelmed in burst into tears again! (First time football related since the Menz went down) I was happy this time with my tears. I only ever needed 1 premiership and now we had 3! It was all too much seeing all 3 cups together.
Billy got to pump up the glory for a third time. I think it all hit home though, looking at a pic of Cameron Ling, on the front of the herald sun, the Monday after the grand final. He was holding all three premiership cups, with the headline ‘Cat Trick’. I loved the pic, but for some reason, about the fourth time I looked at it, I became overwhelmed in burst into tears again! (First time football related since the Menz went down) I was happy this time with my tears. I only ever needed 1 premiership and now we had 3! It was all too much seeing all 3 cups together.
Go the mighty Cats! I’d welcome another cup, don’t get me wrong, but at this stage, its someone else’s turn to share in something so brilliant, so hard, and so rare in nearly 50 years. Jimmy Bartel said it best: ‘I’m so happy, I think I’m going to be sick!’
All that and more on the show that goes through more balls than Roger Federer.
Peace out*.
*Disclaimer: The Sports Lounge may contain 2/3 of your daily fibre intake. No this does not mean we will give you the shits. Warning this last paragraph may not be accurate. Conditions apply and portions of this blog have been edited for your discomfort. Spoken by Tan for the Sports Lounge Party Melbourne (say that last sentence really fast).